Tag Archives: EB1C

EB1-C: Are You a Functional Manager?

Who is the Functional Manager?

The EB-1C visa category allows multinational companies to transfer executives or managers to the U.S., including functional managers who oversee critical organizational functions without direct supervision of employees.

This can be a real boon if want to apply for the EB1-C visa but your position is not an executive one.

According to the USCIS (Chapter 4 - Multinational Executive or Manager), "A petitioning U.S. employer must demonstrate that the beneficiary has been employed for at least one year by a related organization abroad to work in a capacity that is managerial or executive. Managerial capacity includes personnel and function[al] managers while executive capacity focuses on a person's position within an organization."

A functional manager qualifies by managing an essential function (e.g., finance, marketing, or operations) rather than personnel.

What Are Your Chances of Getting An EB1-C Functional Manager Visa?

Functional manager petitions under EB1-C may face lower approval rates due to subjective standards and evidentiary complexities. However, they remain a vital tool for multinational companies transferring specialized leaders, offering speed, flexibility, and alignment with modern organizational models. Success hinges on meticulous documentation that clearly distinguishes strategic management from operational performance, ensuring USCIS recognizes the indispensable nature of the role

According to the USCIS:

A functional manager qualifies by managing an essential function (e.g., finance, marketing, or operations) rather than personnel. Requirements include:

In this context, the definition of the term manager includes function[al] managers. A manager may qualify for multinational manager or executive classification as a function[al] manager if the petitioner can show, among other things, that the beneficiary has and will be primarily managing or directing the management of a function of an organization, even if the beneficiary did not or will not directly supervise any employees.

EB-1C Functional Manager: Key Requirements

A functional manager qualifies by managing an essential function (e.g., finance, marketing, or operations) rather than personnel. Requirements include:

  • Essential Function Management: The role must involve strategic oversight of a core organizational activity, not routine task execution.

  • Senior-Level Authority: The beneficiary must operate at a senior level with discretionary control over daily operations.

  • Documentation: Petitioners must provide organizational charts, job descriptions emphasizing policy development/budgeting, and evidence of the function’s impact on business objectives.

CASE IN POINT
Successful Functional Manager Petition

Financial Planning Director in a Multinational Tech Firm

A director overseeing $500M in mergers and acquisitions successfully qualified by submitting:

Organizational charts showing their role in the C-suite reporting structure.

Board meeting minutes highlighting their influence on investment decisions.

Budget documents proving control over a $20M annual acquisition fund

Let Us Help You Create A Successful EB1-C Functional Manager Business Plan

Contact us today!

Can You Supply the Evidence Required to Show That You Are a Functional Manager?

  1. Evidence of a Clearly Defined and Essential Function
  • Business Plans/Internal Policies: Show the function’s role in achieving organizational goals (e.g., a financial planning team’s impact on mergers and acquisitions).
  • Organizational Charts: Illustrate the function’s place within the company hierarchy and its relationship to other departments. For example, a workflow chart might show how a quality assurance manager oversees standards across production teams without direct reports.
  1. Proof of Managerial (Not Operational) Duties
  • Job Descriptions: Specify the percentage of time spent on strategic tasks (e.g., “70% on budget planning, 30% on cross-departmental coordination”) versus hands-on work. Avoid vague terms like “oversee operations."
  • Delegation Evidence: Demonstrate that routine tasks are assigned to subordinates or automated systems. For instance, a supply chain manager might delegate inventory tracking to software tools, freeing them for supplier negotiations.
  1. Seniority and Discretionary Authority
  • Budget or Policy Control: Submit documents like approved budgets, signed contracts, or policy memos showing the beneficiary’s authority. A marketing director approving a $2M campaign budget qualifies.
  • Hierarchy Comparisons: Compare the role to C-suite positions. A “Head of Remote Work Strategy” might report directly to the CEO, akin to a Chief Operations Officer.
  1. Impact Metrics
  • Performance Reports: Link the function to business outcomes (e.g., “Streamlined compliance processes reduced product launch delays by 30%”).
  • Revenue/Cost Data: For a financial planning manager, show how their strategies increased profitability by 15% year-over-year.
  1. Compliance with the Five-Prong Test

USCIS requires proof that the beneficiary:

  • Manages a clearly defined function (e.g., FP&A, not “general operations”).
  • Oversees an essential function (e.g., cybersecurity in a tech firm).
  • Primarily manages, not performs, the function (e.g., delegating data collection to analysts).
  • Acts at a senior level (e.g., approving departmental budgets).
  • Exercises discretion (e.g., setting R&D priorities without higher approval).

Example from USCIS Precedent

In Matter of G-Inc., a financial planning director was approved by submitting:

  • Organizational charts showing their role in the C-suite.
  • Board meeting minutes highlighting their influence on investment decisions.
  • Metrics linking their strategies to a 20% reduction in operational costs

Strategic Advantages of the Functional Manager Route

Functional manager petitions under EB1-C face lower approval rates due to subjective standards and evidentiary complexities. However, they remain a vital tool for multinational companies transferring specialized leaders, offering speed, flexibility, and alignment with modern organizational models. Success hinges on meticulous documentation that clearly distinguishes strategic management from operational performance, ensuring USCIS recognizes the indispensable nature of the role.

1. No Direct Reports Required

Functional management accommodates roles in flat or matrixed organizations where traditional hierarchies are absent. A cybersecurity lead overseeing threat detection across global teams, for example, can qualify without direct subordinates by demonstrating authority over incident response protocols and budget allocations. This flexibility is invaluable in tech, finance, and R&D sectors, where specialized expertise often outweighs people management needs.

2. Bypassing the PERM Labor Certification

Unlike EB2/EB3 categories, EB1-C avoids the 12–18-month PERM process, which requires proving no qualified U.S. workers are available. For companies expanding rapidly, this acceleration is critical. A fintech firm relocating a blockchain architect from its Singapore office, for instance, could secure green card eligibility in months rather than years.

3. Premium Processing and Faster Timelines

EB1-C petitions qualify for 45-day premium processing (I-140 stage), enabling quicker transitions from L-1A or other temporary visas. A multinational manufacturing company transferring a sustainability director could fast-track their application to align with a product launch timeline.

4. Career Advancement for Technical Experts

Functional management allows specialists to advance into leadership without shifting to people management. A senior engineer overseeing automated production systems, for example, can leverage this category to secure permanent residency while maintaining hands-on involvement in technical innovation.

5. Alignment with Modern Organizational Models

As companies adopt agile methodologies and cross-functional teams, functional managers increasingly drive strategic initiatives. A "Head of Remote Work Strategy" managing hybrid policies across departments exemplifies a role that may lack direct reports but requires high-level coordination and discretionary authority

Let Us Help You Document A Successful EB1-C Functional Manager Business Plan

Contact us today!

In Our Next Post:  How To Make Your Functional Manager Case

Live Business Identity and No More VIBE – 2024 Update

VIBE Gives Way to Live Business Identity

While VIBE has disappeared from the D&B website, it is still listed on the official USCIS website.  Nonetheless, it has long since disappeared and has now been replace by Live Business Identity.

Fortunately, Live Business Identity is also a free option for applicants who need to establish the beneficial ownership of their countries.  The USCIS still requires that submissions for visas such EB1-C or L1 validate the relationship between the parent foreign company and their US-based company.  VIBE has been used to do this:

Validation Instrument for Business Enterprises (VIBE) is a tool designed to enhance USCIS’ adjudications of certain employment-based immigration petitions and applications.

Live Business Identity

VIBE, Validation Instrument for Business Enterprises, Live Business Identity, EB1C, L1, L1A, L1B, BOI, Beneficial Ownership, Beneficial Ownership Information, FinCEN

According to Dun and Bradstreet, Live Business Identity helps ensure you have the most accurate and up-to-date view of organizations. The starting point of Live Business Identity is the Dun & Bradstreet D‑U‑N‑S® Number, a proprietary, unique nine-digit identifier for businesses that allows us to track a business and its related data and connections throughout the full life cycle of that business.

Like personal identities, which are much more than a fingerprint, Live Business Identity goes beyond D‑U‑N‑S to bring in additional valuable elements, such as the identification of connections between entities. Live Business Identity also provides many use-case-specific data elements about a company, including:

  • Device identifiers and IP addresses for targeted digital marketing
    Industry profiles for intelligent sales prospecting
  • Contact information for direct customer connection
  • Extensive payment history for better predictability
  • Entity ownership insights to know who ultimately benefits from a company’s performance.
  • Predictive and prescriptive analytics and scores round out the insights Live Business Identity delivers.

Identifying beneficial ownership is a challenge. Examples of good governance provided by regulators often assume reasonably simplistic hierarchy structures and linkage, and a ‘best case scenario’ where information is readily available. However, this is not the case in the real world. In many regions, the beneficial ownership data that is available is simply not detailed enough, or is inconsistent, meaning it is hard to follow graphs or structures through to get the full picture.

Download DNB Onboard Applied Logic Fact Sheet Here

Benefits of Live Business Identity for USCIS Verification of Beneficiary Ownership 

Comprehensive Data: Live Business Identity provides a 360-degree view of business entities, including information on beneficial ownership structures. This comprehensive data can help government agencies identify and verify the ultimate beneficial owners of companies.

Relationship Mapping: The system can identify hierarchies and beneficial ownership relationships between entities, allowing agencies to better understand complex ownership structures and detect potential risks.

Automated Processes: Live Business Identity enables the automation of verification processes, which can improve efficiency for government agencies tasked with reviewing beneficial ownership information.

Risk Identification: By providing deeper insights into customer, supplier, and partner relationships, the system can help agencies identify both opportunities and risks associated with beneficial ownership structures.

Data Enrichment: Government agencies can use Live Business Identity to enrich and validate the beneficial ownership information they receive from reporting companies, enhancing the accuracy and completeness of their records.

Compliance Support: While not explicitly mentioned in the search results, Live Business Identity's comprehensive data and relationship mapping capabilities could potentially assist agencies in ensuring compliance with beneficial ownership reporting requirements, such as those mandated by the Corporate Transparency Act.

Beneficial Ownership Information

VIBE, Validation Instrument for Business Enterprises, Live Business Identity, EB1C, L1, L1A, L1B, BOI, Beneficial Ownership, Beneficial Ownership Information, FinCEN

In 2021, Congress passed the Corporate Transparency Act on a bipartisan basis. This law creates a new beneficial ownership information reporting requirement as part of the U.S. government’s efforts to make it harder for bad actors to hide or benefit from their ill-gotten gains through shell companies or other opaque ownership structures.

FinCEN's Beneficial Ownership Information is self-reported and its use by an agency like the USCIS is limited by its lack of validation.

FinCEN’s Small Entity Compliance Guide for beneficial ownership information reporting includes the following flowchart to help identify if a company is a reporting company.

VIBE, Validation Instrument for Business Enterprises, Live Business Identity, EB1C, L1, L1A, L1B, BOI, Beneficial Ownership, Beneficial Ownership Information, FinCEN

The rule identifies two types of reporting companies: domestic and foreign. A domestic reporting company is a corporation, limited liability company (LLC), or any entity created by the filing of a document with a secretary of state or any similar office under the law of a state or Indian tribe. A foreign reporting company is a corporation, LLC, or other entity formed under the law of a foreign country that is registered to do business in any state or tribal jurisdiction by the filing of a document with a secretary of state or any similar office. Under the rule, and in keeping with the CTA, twenty-three types of entities are exempt from the definition of “reporting company.”

FinCEN expects that these definitions mean that reporting companies will include (subject to the applicability of specific exemptions) limited liability partnerships, limited liability limited partnerships, business trusts, and most limited partnerships, in addition to corporations and LLCs, because such entities are generally created by a filing with a secretary of state or similar office.

Other types of legal entities, including certain trusts, are excluded from the definitions to the extent that they are not created by the filing of a document with a secretary of state or similar office. FinCEN recognizes that in many states the creation of most trusts typically does not involve the filing of such a formation document.

The Live Business Identity is the most logical choice for validating an enterprise for a visa application.  Live Identify is far easier to navigate than was the VIBE system.  Nonetheless, it can be confusing.  We offer assistance with the process to all of our clients who are seeking visas requiring beneficial ownership validation for their submissions or for their RFEs.